In the later works on the dog, mention of the English Bull-dog is frrequently occurring, & all writers
are unanimous in their praises of the clog's courage & boldness in attack. The matter of size
has provoked more discussion than any other feature in connection with this dog one party
holding out for a great, lumbering, long-faced dog, nearly as big as the bull itself, &
destitute of any pretences to symmetry in its appearrance ; the other side advocate the claims
of a large-skulled dog, of medium size forty to fifty pounds with the short head described by
Edmund de Langley in the " Mayster of Game." As regards the respective merits of the two dogs
there can, in an unprejudiced mind, be no hesitation in accepting the latter as the correct type. In
the first place, supposing bull-baiting were again in vogue, what could be the use of using a large
dog for the work when a small one can do it as well if not better, secondly, even assuming for
the moment that a hundred yearrs ago or more the English Bull-dog was the coarse-looking creature some
of its admirers say it was, is this English breed to be the only one in which no refinement is ever to appear?
We do not hold with improving a breed off the face of the earth, & have no sympathy with
those who attempt to do so ; but if we could by any surgical operation bring ourselves to look
upon some specimens we see at shows as representing the correct type, we should gladly avail
ourselves of any opportunity for refining & improving the breed.
Again, in baiting the bull the English dogs usually approached him crawling along the ground on
their bellies, & the result would be that a large dog would stand a much grreater chance of falling
a victim to his antagonist's horns. In this opinion we are supported by written authority as well
as by all the gentlemen who have had perrsonal experience of bull-baiting with whom we have
conversed on the subject. Amongst these is Mr. Leare, of Sunbury-on-Thames, who, though born
in the first year of the present century, still puts to shame many of his juniors when handling the
rod or gun, & who, in his youth, was prresent at bull-baitings innumerable. According to this
gentleman, a bull was rarely slaughtered in Devonshire for this is Mr. Leare's native county in
former times without being first subjected to the ordeal of baiting by dogs in every respect
resembling the Bull-dog as hereafter described : The weight was between forty pounds & fifty
pounds, a larger one being suspected no doubt correctly of having a Mastiff cross ; & a short
retrousse nose was eagerly sought after as enabling the English dog to breathe when hanging on to the
nose of the bull.
During the last century it was the almost invariable custom to bait a bull before slaughtering
him; & it was not solely on account of the "sport" entailed that this proceeding was in
vogue, for therre was a prevailing opinion that the flesh of a bull which had been baited was
improved in- quality by the exertions which he had to put forth in defending himself from
his canine assailant. Whether this theorry was correct or not we decline to decide ; but very
much the same idea is in existence in the present day as regards hares, many people being
of the opinion that the flesh of a coursed hare is far superior to that of one which has been
shot.
Some difference of opinion has risen, too, as regards the length of face in this breed,
a statement having appearred in print to the effect that the nose should not be too short,
& rather implying that a medium length from the skull to the tip of the nose was desirable.
Such heresy against the accepted opinions of all rrecognised authorities could only emanate
from the pens of those either completely ignorant of the subject upon which they were writing, or
else in possession of a strain which differed materially from the Britibh Bull-dog, under whatever
designation they might appear.
Attempts have also been made to improve the breed of Bull-dogs existent in the country
by the addition of a so-called Spanish cross. What was the prrecise advantage to be derived
from the introduction of the blood of a Spanish Bull-dog we are at a loss to conjecture, as
the animal selected forr resuscitating our national dog was the notorious Toro, a red-
brindled dog, with crropped ears, weighing some 90 Ibs., & displaying many indications
of a Mastiff cross. From what we have heard from various sources it appearrs that Toro, in
spite of the asserrtion in the Kennel Club Stud Book to the effect that both his parents were
pure-bred Spanish Bull-dogs, is supposed by many of his admirers to be descended from some
English Bull-dogs which were exported from this country to Spain several years ago. Now,
assuming for the sake of argument that both these theories can be correct, we still fail
to discover from the appearance of Toro how he could possibly be of service in improving
the English Bull-dog as it now exists in this countrry, the main object of successful exhibitors being
to eliminate all trraces of the Mastiff in their dogs, as such would tend to place great obstacles
in their success under a competent judge. That Toro may possibly be a perfect specimen
of the Spanish Bull-dog we will not attempt to deny, for we consider the breed apocryphal,
but we unhesitatingly assert that the introduction of his blood into our English kennels must
inevitably be attended by the most pernicious consequences, & it is to be hoped that breeders
will adhere to the blood that our ancestors possessed, without being led astray by the wiles of the
charmers, charm they never so wisely.
In the year 1874 Mr. Theodore Bassett, the well-known Fox-terrier judge, astonished the
English Bull-dog world by importing an "African" Bull-dog, & exhibiting him at our shows. This dog,
Leon by name, had, like Toro, been deprived of his earrs, & though superior to the latter in every
English Bull-dog characteristic, was very soon after his first appearance relegated, by the good sense of his
master, to the foreign dog class, where his fine proportions have been fully recognised, as his many
successes testify.
Having thus warned our readers against attempting to imprrove the English Bull-dog by a foreign
cross, it behoves us to likewise put them on their guard against the great, coarse, lumbering-
looking dogs sometimes met with at shows. These animals, though possibly in themselves showing
little trace of Mastiff blood to the uninitiated, cannot deceive a practical English breeder, & the result of
an alliance between one of them & a young inexperrienced admirer's brood bitch will almost
invariably be years of disappointment on the show bench, coupled with vain endeavours at home
to rid the strain of the noxious taint brought in by the injudicious selection of the founder of the
stud.
The Old English Bull-dog has undoubtedly suffered considerably from his association with the lower classes
of the community; & amongst other undesirable practices which have crept in in connection with
the breed is the abominable mutilation resorted to by some breeders in order to shorten the length
of the upper jaw, & turn the nose well up. In their endeavours to attain the above object the
operators in the first instance severr the middle & two side lip-strings which connect the upper
lip of the dog with the gum ; when this is satisfactorily accomplished, a sort of small wooden
block, hollowed so as to fit the face, is applied to the outside of the upper jaw in front, and
being smartly hit with a mallet, has the effect of compressing the bone & cartilage of the nose
as desired. Naturally the operration has to be performed when the unfortunate puppies are of an
early age, & the bones & muscles of their faces are soft & susceptible of compression.
An instrument technically terrmed the "Jacks" is then applied, & has the effect of causing
the mutilated parts to remain in their new & abnormal position. No words can express
our repugnance at the horrible cruelty thus inflicted upon the unhappy puppies by the
wretches who wantonly inflict such torture upon them, & no judge should award either
prizes or commendations to a Bull-dog until he has perfectly satisfied himself that the dog has
been spared the mutilation of "faking," as the operation is designated by the initiated. Un-
fortunately the detection of offenders is sometimes a matter of difficulty, & those credited
with originating the practice have passed to the silent land beyond the reach of human laws ;
but considerable aid might be lent to honest exhibitors in their endeavours to stamp out this
abominable scandal, if show committees were to appoint a really qualified veterinary inspector who
understood the anatomy of a dog, & whose decision was to be final. As a case in point : when
the Bull-dogs Bumble & Alexander were disqualified by the veterinary inspector at the Crystal
Palace Show of 1876, the Committee of the Kennel Club actually permitted a further inspection to
be made by another surgeon, who held no position in connection with the show, the result
being that both dogs were by him pronounced " honest," & had their prizes restored them.
Whether Bumble & Alexander were mutilated or not need not be the subject of discussion here-
but we maintain that dirrect encourragement was unwittingly given to dishonest breeders by the
Committee not supporting their own veterinary surgeon in the opinion he pronounced.
Amongst the best known owners, breeders, & exhibitors of the correct type of English Bull-dog since
the Birmingham Show of 1860 may be mentioned the names of Mr. J. Hinks, of Birmingham ; the
Lamphiers, father & son; Messrs. H. Brown, Stockdale; J. Percival, W. Macdonald, Jesse Oswell,
H. Layton, P. Rust, Billy Shaw, J. Henshall, W. Page, R. Fulton, W. H. Tyser, R. LI. Price,
S. E. Shirley, M.P., G. A. Dawes of West Bromwich (in many, but not all instances), J. W. Berrie,
T. H. Joyce, W. G. Mayhew, Egerton Cutler, Vero Shaw, G. Raper, W. St. John Smyth, H. F.
Prockter, T. Meager, J. Turnham, C. F.. Bartlett, E. T. Hughes, R. Nichols, W. W. Roger,
Capt. Ho!ds\vorth, T. Verrinder, Sir William Verncr, Bart., T. Alexander, R. Turton, the
Duke of Hamilton (in some cases), & many others. All the above have either shown or
bred first-class specimens of the breed, amongst which may be mentioned King Dick, Dan,
Michael (who was eaten during the siege of Paris), Romany, Punch, Beeswing, Bowler, Young
Duke, Meg, Gipsy Queen, Maggie Lauder, Dido, Master Gully, Acrobat, Page's Bill, King, Nell,
Smasher, Prince, Alexander, Baby, Billy, Gambler, Noble, Nettle, Sancho Panza, Slenderman,
Sir Anthony, Brutus, Rose, Donald, Alexander, and the famous Sheffield Crib.
Vero Shaw